Vol. 33 No. 3 (2024): Nordic Journal of African Studies
General articles

Rethinking Language: The Need for Language Supportive Pedagogies in Teacher Training in Tanzania

Gastor Mapunda
University of Dar es Salaam
Tracey Costley
University of Essex
Hannah Gibson
University of Essex
Nancy Kula
Leiden University/LUCL and University of the Free State
Colin Reilly
University of Essex

Published 2024-09-30

Keywords

  • multilingualism,
  • teacher training,
  • language policy,
  • education,
  • Tanzania

How to Cite

Mapunda, G., Costley, T., Gibson, H., Kula, N., & Reilly, C. (2024). Rethinking Language: The Need for Language Supportive Pedagogies in Teacher Training in Tanzania. Nordic Journal of African Studies, 33(3), 184–202. https://doi.org/10.53228/njas.v33i3.1025

Abstract

The importance of language is consistently ignored within teacher training across Africa, with training designed based on the assumption that learners are fully competent in the medium of instruction (MOI). This causes widespread challenges and often means that children cannot access education in a familiar language. This is particularly true at the primary level, where the familiar languages of the children may not be the same as the specified medium of instruction. Focusing on Tanzania, this paper discusses the need to embed language supportive pedagogies into teacher training at all levels, but particularly at the primary level. The paper discusses interviews with key stakeholders in education which illustrate language attitudes and language use within the classroom. Data from these interviews also highlights the challenges which teachers face relating to language, and the creative methods they use to resolve these challenges. We argue that monolingual approaches to language-in-education are not effective, and that formal training in multilingual, language supportive pedagogies is required to provide teachers with the skills they need to effectively engage with multilingual classrooms. Based on multilingual realities, we make practical suggestions for language supportive pedagogies. We view these pedagogies as an essential factor in teacher training which is linked to wider notions of access and equality, but which is currently being overlooked.

 

Umuhimu wa lugha katika mafunzo ya walimu ni suala linaloendelea kupuuzwa barani Afrika. Mara nyingi mafunzo ya ualimu yanapoandaliwa inachukuliwa kuwa wanafunzi wote wanaifahamu vizuri lugha ya kujifunzia na kufundishia (LKK). Suala hili linasababisha changamoto kubwa, na mara nyingi hudhaniwa kwamba watoto hawawezi kupata elimu zao za asili wanazozimudu vizuri. Hali hii hujitokeza zaidi katika ngazi ya elimu ya msingi, ambapo lugha ambayo watoto wanaifahamu mara nyingi inatofautiana na lugha rasmi ya kujifunzia na kufundishia. Kwa kutumia Tanzania kama kifani cha uchunguzi, makala hii inajadili umuhimu wa kuwa na mtaala unaozingatia lugha katika mafunzo ya ualimu katika ngazi zote hususani katika ngazi ya elimu ya msingi. Makala inatumia data za usaili kutoka kwa wadau muhimu wa elimu kuhusu mitazamo ya matumizi ya lugha darasani. Data zinazotokana na usaili zinahusu changamoto za lugha ambazo walimu hukabiliana nazo, na mbinu bunifu wanazozitumia kuzikabili. Hoja yetu ni kwamba mbinu za utumizi wa lugha moja katika elimu si faafu katika mazingira ya wingilugha, na mafunzo rasmi yahusuyo ufundishaji unaozingatia lugha katika mazingira ya wingilugha yanahitajika ili kuwapa walimu maarifa wanayohitaji ili kufundisha vyema madarasa yenye wingilugha. Kulingana na uhalisia wa wingilugha, tunatoa mapendekezo ya mtazamo huu wa mafunzo ya ualimu kuwa kigezo muhimu katika mafunzo ya ualimu ambacho kinahusishwa moja kwa moja na mawazo mapana ya upatikanaji na usawa, masuala ambayo kwa sasa hayazingatiwi.

References

  1. Adamson, Laela. 2022. “Fear and Shame: Students’ Experiences in English-medium Secondary Classrooms in Tanzania.” Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development: 1–16.
  2. Barrett, Angeline M. 2014. Language, Learning and Textbooks: Findings from Baseline Survey of Form 1 students and teachers. Bristol: University of Bristol.
  3. Barrett, Angeline M. and David Bainton. 2016. “Re-interpreting Relevant Learning: An Evaluative Framework for Secondary Education in a Global Language.” Comparative Education 52 (3): 392–407.
  4. Barrett, Angeline M., Zawadi Richard Juma, and Francis William. 2021. “Processes of Pedagogic Change: Integrating Subject and Language Learning through Teacher Education.” In Multilingual Learning and Language Supportive Pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Elizabeth Erling, John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly, 255–272. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  5. Barrett, Angeline M., Noah Mtana, Kalafunja Osaki, and Casmir Rubagumya. 2014. Baseline Study Report, Strengthening Secondary Education in Practice: Language Supportive Teaching and Textbooks in Tanzania (LSTT). Bristol: University of Bristol.
  6. Clegg, John. 2015. “Developing Readable English-medium Textbooks in Rwanda.” Unpublished paper presented at the 49th Annual International IATEFL Conference and Exhibition, Manchester, UK, April 11–14.
  7. Clegg, John. 2021. “Multilingual Learning in Anglophone Sub-Saharan Africa: How to Help Children Use All Their Languages to Learn.” In Multilingual Learning and Language Supportive Pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Elizabeth Erling, John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly, 144–169. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  8. Clegg, John, and Oksana Afitska. 2011. “Teaching and Learning in Two Languages in African Classrooms.” Comparative Education 47 (1): 61–77.
  9. Clegg, John, and Lizzi O. Milligan. 2021. “Multilingual Learning and Language-Supportive Teaching in Rwandan Learning Materials.” In Multilingual Learning and Language Supportive Pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Elizabeth Erling, John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly, 201–227. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  10. Costley, Tracey, and Constant Leung. 2020. “Putting Translanguaging into Practice: A View from England.” System 92: 102270.
  11. Costley, Tracey, and Colin Reilly. 2021. “Methodological Principles for Researching Multilingually: Reflections on Linguistic Ethnography.” TESOL Quarterly 55 (3): 1035–1047.
  12. David, Opanga, and Nsengimana Venuste. 2021. “Practice in Teaching and Learning of Invertebrates: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Pedagogical Language Strategies in Tanzania Secondary Schools.” Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education 17 (2): em1940.
  13. Dearden, Julie. 2014. English as a Medium of Instruction: A Growing Global Phenomenon. British Council.
  14. Erling, Elizabeth J. 2014. Role of English in Skills Development in South Asia. British Council India.
  15. Erling, Elizabeth. J., Philip Seargeant, and Michael Solly. 2014. “English in Rural Bangladesh: How is Language Education Perceived as a Resource for Development in Rural Communities?” English Today 30 (4): 15-21.
  16. Erling, Elizabeth J., John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly, eds. 2021a. Multilingual Learning and Language Supportive Pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  17. Erling, Elizabeth J., John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly. 2021b. “Introduction: multilingual learning and language supportive pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa. In Multilingual Learning and Language Supportive Pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa edited by Erling, Elizabeth J., John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly, 1-30. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  18. Foster, Danny. 2023. “Language of Instruction Attitudes in Rural Tanzania: Parental Discourses and Valued Linguistic Capabilities”. In Multilingual Learning: Assessment, Ideologies and Policies in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Colin Reilly, Feliciano Chimbutane, John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Elizabeth J. Erling, 123–145. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  19. Goodson, Lisa, and Caroline Tagg. 2018. “Using Research Vignettes to Explore Co-production in a Large Diverse Team: Implications for Research in Superdiverse Contexts.” In The Routledge Handbook of Language and Superdiversity, edited by Angela Creese and Adrian Blackledge, 103-117. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  20. Hardman, Frank, Jan Abd-Kadir, and Audax Tibuhinda. 2012. “Reforming Teacher Education in Tanzania.” International Journal of Educational Development 32 (6): 826–834.
  21. Komba, Sotco Claudius, and Rehema Japhet Mwakabenga. 2019. “Teacher Professional Development in Tanzania: Challenges and Opportunities.” Educational Leadership: 1–12.
  22. Lüpke, Friederike, and Ibrahima Abdoul Hayou Cissé. 2023. “Legitimising Fluid Multilingual Practices: A Challenge for Formal Education Worldwide.” In Multilingual Learning: Assessment, Ideologies and Policies in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Colin Reilly, Feliciano Chimbutane, John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Elizabeth J. Erling, 43–64. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  23. Mapunda, Gastor. 2021. Athari ya Sera ya Taifa ya Lugha kwa Lugha za Asili: Mfano wa Lugha ya Kingoni, Kusini mwa Tanzania [The Effect of the National Language Policy on Community Languages: The Example of the Ngoni Language in Southern Tanzania]. In Chebanne, A. and A. Lesekelo (Eds). African Languages: Linguistic, Literary and Social Issues. Cape Town. UWC/CASAS. ISBN 978-92-0-447014-7. (pp. 470-482).
  24. Mapunda, Gastor, and Hannah Gibson. 2022. “On the Suitability of Swahili for Early Schooling in Remote Rural Tanzania: Do Policy and Practice Align?” Journal of the British Academy 10 (s4).
  25. Milligan, Lizzi. O., John Clegg, and Leon Tikly. 2016. “Exploring the Potential for Language Supportive Learning in English Medium Instruction: A Rwandan Case Study.” Comparative Education 52 (3): 328–342.
  26. Mradi wa Lugha za Tanzania. 2009. Atlasi ya Lugha za Tanzania. Dar es Salaam: LOT.
  27. Mtavangu, Norbert. 2002. Students’ Attitudes towards French Language and the Socioeconomic Benefits Accruing from Learning It. MA Linguistics Dissertation, University of Dar es Salaam.
  28. Reilly, Colin, Mompoloki M. Bagwasi, Tracey Costley, Hannah Gibson, Nancy C. Kula, Gastor Mapunda, and Joseph Mwansa. 2022. “‘Languages Don’t Have Bones, So You Can Just Break Them’: Rethinking Multilingualism in Education Policy and Practice in Africa.” Journal of the British Academy 10 (s4): 1–20.
  29. Reilly, Colin, Rajendra Chetty, Opanga David, and Hannah Gibson. Forthcoming. “The Violence of Monolingualism: Examining the Effects of Coloniality in Language-in-Education Policy”. Decolonial Subversions.
  30. Reilly, Colin, Tracey Costley, Hannah Gibson, Nancy C. Kula, Mompoloki M. Bagwasi, Dikosha Dikosha, Phetso Mmolao, Joseph M. Mwansa, Martha Mwandia, Gastor Mapunda, and Edna James. 2023. “Emerging Principles for Researching Multilingually in Linguistic Ethnography: Reflections from Botswana, Tanzania, the UK and Zambia.” Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development 44 (8): 689–701.
  31. Richard, Juma Zawadi, and Opanga David. 2021. “Language Supportive Pedagogy as a Tool for Improving Science Teaching and Learning in Tanzania: Case of Dodoma Secondary Schools.” Journal of Research Innovation and Implications in Education 5 (2): 50–60.
  32. Rubagumya, Casmir. M, Eliakimu Sane, and Jesse Julius Ndabakurane. 2021. “Vignette: Implementing language supportive pedagogy to support content learning in Tanzania.” In Multilingual Learning and Language Supportive Pedagogies in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Elizabeth Erling, John Clegg, Casmir Rubagumya, and Colin Reilly, 170–174. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
  33. Shank Lauwo, Monica. 2022. “Language Ideologies in Multilingual Tanzania: Parental Discourses, School Realities, and Contested Visions of Schooling.” Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development 43 (7): 679–693.
  34. Swai, Calvin Zakaria, Josephat Paul Nkaizirwa, Alfred Kisuda Hugo, Cosmas Ayelwisye Mahenge, and Philbert Sixbert Komba. 2022. “Strengthening Teacher Education in Tanzania: Student-Teachers’ and Tutors’ Satisfaction with College Facilities and Environment.” Cogent Education 9 (1): 2070053.
  35. Tarmo, Albert. 2016. “Pre-service Science Teachers’ Epistemological Beliefs and Teaching Reforms in Tanzania.” Cogent Education 3 (1): 1-20.
  36. TIE. 2019. National Curriculum Framework for Basic and Teacher Education. Dar es Salaam: Ministry of Education, Science and Technology.
  37. UNESCO. 2016. “If You Don’t Understand, How Can You Learn?” Global Education Monitoring Report, Policy Paper 24. UNESCO.
  38. UWEZO. 2011. Are our children Learning? Annual Learning Assessment Report. Dar es Salaam: UWEZO Tanzania. (Available at www.uwezo.net)
  39. William, Francis, and Jesse Julius Ndabakurane. 2017. “Language Supportive Teaching and Textbooks (LSTT) for Bilingual Classrooms Mathematics Teaching and Learning in Tanzania”. Africa Journal of Teacher Education 6 (1): 96–118.